WINNER OF ICELAND'S FIRST PIZZA CHAMPIONSHIP

WINNER OF ICELAND'S FIRST PIZZA CHAMPIONSHIP

WINNER OF ICELAND'S FIRST PIZZA CHAMPIONSHIP

Ismail Mesnaoui of Pizza Popolare holding the first place trophy and certificate at Iceland's first pizza championship, with judge Paolo Parravano and organiser Eggert Jónsson

On 28 April 2026 Iceland held its first national pizza championship, and the pizza maker who won it works at our counter in Pósthús Mathöll. Ismail Mesnaoui beat a field that included some of the best known pizzerias in the country, and the judges flew in from Italy to say so.


The competition

The championship was organised by Eggert Jónsson, a baker and pastry chef, and held in the test kitchen of ÓJK-ÍSAM in Reykjavík. The rules were simple: no frozen dough, quality ingredients only, one pizza judged on dough, technique and taste.


The judging panel came mostly from Italy. Paolo Parravano and Remo Nafra both work for the flour producer Polselli and travel the world judging competitions like this one. They were joined by Alfio Mironi, a food journalist with Ciociaria e Cucina, and Elínrós Líndal, who edits the food section at mbl.is.


Competitors came from Hornið (Iceland’s oldest pizzeria, whose owner Jakob Magnússon, with more than forty years of pizza behind him, assisted his daughter Ólöf Helga), Flatbakan, Eldofninn, Minigarðurinn, Public Deli, Castello, Gott and Ölverk, among others. According to the organiser the final was close.


What Ismail baked

A classic Italian pizza, built from the kind of ingredients we use every day: Strianese tomato sauce, slow-cooked cherry tomatoes, anchovies, caperberries, stracciatella, garlic, lemon thyme, basil and extra virgin olive oil.


Second place went to Mika Józefik of restaurant Mika in Reykholt, with a pizza topped with a skyr-based sauce, artichokes, chocolate-cured salmon, yuzu, dill and cacao nibs. Third was Logi Brynjarsson of SV veitingar, who runs one of the largest staff canteens in the country, at Alvotech, and whose dough the organiser singled out.


The prize was a trip to Italy: a pizza course run by Polselli and a tour of the best pizzerias in Naples.


Why it matters to you

Pizza in Iceland used to mean a thick, heavily topped takeaway pie. This championship exists because that has changed. A handful of places now make pizza the way it’s made in Naples, and the standard is high enough that Italian judges found the final hard to call.


We’ve been in the 50 Top Pizza Europe guide three years running, in 2024, 2025 and 2026, and now the person stretching the dough at our counter is the national champion. If you want to taste what won, come in. We’re in Pósthús Mathöll at Pósthússtræti 5, a minute from Austurvöllur, open 11:30 to 22:00 every day. The Marinara Popolare on our menu (tomato, roasted cherry tomatoes, garlic, anchovies, capers, basil, oregano) is the closest thing to Ismail’s competition pizza.


Source: mbl.is, 29 April 2026, “Ismail á Pizza Popolare valinn besti pítsubakari Íslands” by Elínrós Líndal. Read the original (Icelandic).