What is Pizza Napoletana Contemporanea? The style we make in Reykjavík

What is Pizza Napoletana Contemporanea? The style we make in Reykjavík

What is Pizza Napoletana Contemporanea? The style we make in Reykjavík

Margherita with a tall, leopard-spotted crust, an example of Pizza Napoletana Contemporanea at Pizza Popolare, Reykjavík

People ask at the counter why the rim is so high. The short answer is that we make Pizza Napoletana Contemporanea, a style that grew out of Naples over the last fifteen years or so, and the rim is the point. Here's the longer answer.

Classic Neapolitan first

Traditional Neapolitan pizza is the one with a protected definition: soft, thin in the middle, a modest puffed edge, baked in a wood-fired oven at around 450°C for sixty to ninety seconds. Tomato, mozzarella, basil, olive oil. It's eaten with a knife and fork because the centre is too soft to lift. That's the pizza Naples has made for a century and a half.

What changed

A generation of Neapolitan pizza makers started pushing the dough further: more water, longer fermentation, gentler handling, and a bake that puffs the rim up into something tall and open, like good bread. The result is a crust you can see through when you tear it, with a leopard-spotted char on the outside, and a centre that's still soft but holds its toppings better. The Italians call it contemporanea, contemporary, or sometimes canotto, dinghy, because the rim looks inflated.

It's not a different recipe so much as a different ambition. The flour is still Italian, the oven still runs hot, the toppings are still few. But the dough is treated as the main event, and the toppings are chosen to sit on a crust that can carry them: burrata, nduja, cured meats laid on after the bake, honey over blue cheese.

How we make ours

Our dough has no sugar and no shortcuts; it's naturally fermented, and we use D.O.P. ingredients where they exist: San Marzano tomatoes, the right flour, fresh mozzarella. Where we can, we bring in Icelandic ingredients that earn their place, like the three cheeses from Erpsstaðir on the 4 Formaggi and the blue cheese on the Parma Popolare.

This is the style that put us in the 50 Top Pizza Europe guide in 2024, 2025 and 2026, the only Icelandic pizzeria on that list, and that won Ismail Mesnaoui, who runs our oven, Iceland's first national pizza championship in April 2026.

What to order to taste the difference

Start with a Margherita (3,190 kr). It's the test of any pizzeria and the one where the dough has nowhere to hide. Then, if you come back, the Nduja (4,290 kr): San Marzano, spicy nduja and burrata stracciatella, which only works on a crust strong enough to hold the burrata. Or the San Marzano e Stracciatella (4,190 kr) if you want the dough and the tomato with nothing in the way.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between Neapolitan and contemporary Neapolitan pizza?

Hydration, fermentation and the rim. Contemporanea uses a wetter, longer-fermented dough that bakes into a much taller, airier crust. The centre is firmer than classic Neapolitan, so toppings like burrata and cured meats hold.

Is it eaten with a knife and fork?

Either way. The crust is strong enough to pick up a slice; most Italians still use a knife and fork for the soft centre.

Why is the crust charred?

The leopard spotting comes from a very hot oven and a well-fermented dough. It's flavour, not a mistake.

Where can I eat Pizza Napoletana Contemporanea in Reykjavík?

At Pizza Popolare in Pósthús Mathöll, Pósthússtræti 5, open 11:30 to 22:00 every day.